Skip to main content

My quick thoughts, back stage, and rants as I try to Teach kids about the Web while learning how to help others build a better Web.

IndieWebRing

Come Journey Through the IndieWeb Sites

🕸💍

Greg McVerry

Reflections on #credweb Community Group 2020-04-08 Meeting

Yesterday the credible web group got together to do some though excercises as we get closer to building a credibility rating engine. We began, and I

4 min read

Yesterday the credible web group got together to do some though excercises as we get closer to building a credibility rating engine.

We began, and I did not have time to participate by rating credibility of public figures. You can see an example on the Google Doc using this framework.

I would rather link the credibility rating to a person canonical website than a social media silo but the tools we are trying to develop are directed more at social networks and journalistic publishers.

Still having your own place online is the first step to credibility and I think we should try to "attach" ratings to a person canonical ID. Not having a website, while a reflection of priviledge, is in itself a loss of credibility.

We then tried this thought excercise and didn't finish in the hour call because this stuff is hard. Common problems we had : should credibility be domain specific? is action required? how big of a scale do we need to ensure enough variance but not threaten internal consitency?

My thoughts

Some quick bytes:

  • you can't separate expertise from domain
    • we discussed relying on   self affirmed expertise. "I know Sandro. I know he is an expert in web standards. Sandro says he is an expert in auto mechanics. Therefore I trust Sandro with my car." This to me is way too fraught with engendered and cultural bias. A white male from the dominant narrative is way quicker to label themselves an expert
  • The action kept throwing me. Must we have an action be involved on a credibility rating?
    • The US  Georgia Governor said, "We just learned how contagious covid-19 is" I now trust him less. Not going tochange my actions. I would love to give him 4 pinnochio noses in my credibility browser extension

Is 1st degree and  2nd degree network effect enough?
I feel like I kind of already include credibility statements for the people I follow: https://jgregorymcverry.com/myfollowing

  • each person is arranged by domain of knowledge. I do include their first person expertise statements.
  • I have four different levels of trust "acquaintance, colleague, friend, muse" I use xfn for this like rel="muse"

This isn't a solution for the cred web work, just another example.. It isn't json-ld. It parses into JSON well so converting it to extra data to stick somewhere in the file wouldn't be hard once there are tools to try http://pin13.net/mf2/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fjgregorymcverry.com%2Ffollowing (the pinochio broswer extension doesn't exist).

I follow Sandro and he is more than acquaintance. He follows Subbu and says he is an expert in journalism. Therefore when I follow Subbu he gets some credibility points toward journalism. The more 2nd degree points Subbu gets the higher Subbu's credibility rating on a goven domain.


This is a little suspect to confirmation bias. Hard to eliminate the "being human part" and the idea that there is ever an objective credibility rating is nonsensical.

Can we annotate for credibility?
Back to the Kemp example. If I read this: https://www.newsweek.com/georgia-governor-didnt-know-asymptomatic-people-transmit-coronavirus-149569... I would want to be able to do something like:

<blockquote> <a class="h-card" href="https://gov.georgia.gov/" tag="dumbass"> Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp </a> said he wasn't aware that asymptomatic people could transmit coronavirus as he announced he was preparing to issue a state-wide shelter-in-place order. <cite> <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/georgia-governor-didnt-know-asymptomatic-people-transmit-coronavirus-1495695"> Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp Says He Didn't Know Asymptomatic People Could Transmit Coronavirus </a> </cite> </blockquote>

If enough 2nd degree people gave Brian Kemp a dumbass rating in my network then my browser would then add four pinochios, four pants on fire, whatever, after any Brtian Kemp mention that also linked to any georgia.gov page


Sorry for not using JSON-LD. I do not know it well enough yet. Easier for me to think in way where I can make my text and metatdata human readable at the same time. I will try and figure out how to mark up my example and add the data back in again  as JSON-LD.

Greg McVerry

Update on our @goifoundation #IndieWeb and #OER Ghana project sponsored by @MozillaOpenLeaders and @scsu

Great post from Abby about our Mozilla Open Leaders IndieWeb and #OER Ghana project in Accra, Ghana. Please give it a read and then share

3 min read

Great post from Abby about our Mozilla Open Leaders IndieWeb and Ghana project in Accra, Ghana. Please give it a read and then share our GoFundMe. History
I am on the Advisory Board to the Global Open Initiative Foundation in Accra, Ghana. Last year Southern Connectuct State University provided $200 seed money to pay for hosting costs for Sadik, a founder, and I  to start a club encouraging people to build personal websites and take control of their social stream.


Mozilla Open Leader Fellowship

After getting the program up and running Sadik and I were awarded a fellowship from Mozilla to develop the program and then train an additional ten leaders in Ghana to start clubs back on their campuses. The goal is  to create an Open Educational Resource network across Ghana.
https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/indieweb-and-oer-ghana-open-leaders-x-program/

IndieWeb and OER Ghana | an Open Leaders X program Mozilla is a global nonprofit dedicated to keeping the Internet a global public resource that is open and accessible to all. foundation.mozilla.org

We are launching the 10 week program in February and will conclude with a two day Camp in Accra, Ghana.

We also have a massive network of experts across many disciplines to help members craft high quality teaching materials and running events: https://wiki.goifnetwork.org/Our_Mozilla_OLX_Volunteers


Sadik and I have also been busy working on curriculum, trainign guides, and support club leaders will need. The curriculum  https://wiki.goifnetwork.org/OER_Ghana:_Mozilla_Leaders_X_Training_Curriculum  is based off of a class I teach at Southern  https://edu106.jgregorymcverry.com/

Elm City Webmakers


A similar club is relaunching in New Haven called the Elm City Webmakers: http://elmcitywebmakers.com/. I used to run it on campus. This club will offer after school training for all ages, students, parents, grandparents. We begin on Monday! It is cosponsored by Concepts for Adaptive Learning and Junta.

Like the Ghana program anyone who shows up will get a free website. We will also have a free chat room and a wiki for students to share ideas.
We are currently applying for grants to secure free transportation for  Hamden and NHPS students.


Please Help

I applied for a social justice grant and a sabbatical to support this work but I unfortunately wasn't awarded either. Luckily Nate Angell  set up a fundraiser and will donate all the money to the Global Open Initiative. 

Can you share the link to the Mozilla post and to our fundraiser, GoFundMe,  across your networks?

CLMOOC

Prev | Home | Join | ? | Next